Building Loyalty: A Guide to Rewards Programs and Measuring Success

Loyalty programs have long been a cornerstone for brands wanting to build a loyal customer base, increase repeat purchases, and drive revenue. But designing a successful loyalty program requires a strategic approach to choosing rewards, tracking success metrics, and continuous improvement.

What is a customer loyalty program?

It's well known that a business can’t just open its doors and expect a flood of customers to walk in. People need a compelling reason to buy, and keep buying! While a great product or memorable customer experience often does the trick, there are times when brands need a more intentional approach to keep customers engaged and coming back for more. This is where a strong customer loyalty program comes into play.

While a referral program is a program designed to encourage existing customers to recommend products or services to friends and family, often incentivized with rewards like discounts, cash, or freebies, a customer loyalty program is a retention strategy designed to reward repeat customers with benefits, encouraging them to continue purchasing from a specific brand. Whether through points, discounts, or exclusive perks, these programs create a reciprocal relationship with customers, building trust and fostering long-term loyalty.

The benefits of a well-designed program are clear: both customer retention and revenue growth get a boost. Queue-it reports that 84% of consumers are more likely to stick with a brand that offers a loyalty program, and 66% adjust their spending to maximize benefits. Brands with loyalty programs, like Amazon and Walmart, also see higher overall spending.

A customer-centric loyalty program can drive revenue, increase engagement, and strengthen brand loyalty. But to unlock this potential, the program’s structure, rewards, and metrics must be carefully crafted.

How do customer loyalty programs work?

By encouraging repeat purchases and engagement, loyalty programs create a win-win scenario: customers feel valued, and businesses see a boost in retention and lifetime value. Here’s how the general process works:

• Customer makes a purchase or provides information: A new customer interacts with the brand, either by making their first purchase or providing their contact details.
• Sign-up prompt: The brand invites the customer to join its loyalty program, often offering an incentive for signing up.
• Rewards for purchases: Once enrolled, the customer earns rewards, whether points, discounts, or exclusive offers, every time they make a purchase or engage with the brand.
• Ongoing benefits: As the customer continues to engage, they unlock even better rewards, creating a cycle that encourages repeat business.

For example, Lululemon’s Like New Program encourages customers to trade in gently used gear for store credit. In return, members receive discounts on pre-owned items, early access to new releases, and exclusive fitness events. The more customers engage, the more rewards they unlock, blending sustainability with personalized perks to foster long-term loyalty.

There are several types of loyalty programs, such as point-based systems, referral incentives, and tiered programs, which can be combined in various ways to provide the most value to customers while driving business growth.

Basic rewards and choosing the right incentives

Rewards structure

When designing a loyalty program, start with a structure that’s simple for customers to understand and easy to participate in. Some of the most popular options include:

• Points-based system: Customers earn points for every dollar spent, which can be redeemed for discounts or products. For example, Amazon’s Prime Rewards Visa Card offers 5% cash back on Amazon and Whole Foods purchases.
• Tiered rewards: Rewards increase based on customer spending or engagement. Airlines like Delta use loyalty tiers that offer perks such as priority boarding, free checked bags, and lounge access.
• Paid programs: For a subscription fee, customers gain access to exclusive rewards. For instance, Sephora’s Beauty Insider Program beauty insider program offers paid members perks like free shipping early access to launches and vip events which helps drive loyalty repeat purchases.

Choosing the best rewards

Selecting the right rewards is key to the success of your loyalty program, as it directly influences customer engagement and satisfaction. According to KPMG, 75% of consumers are more likely to make a purchase if a loyalty program offers rewards they find relevant. The goal is to offer rewards that truly resonate with your audience, making them feel valued and excited to stay loyal.

Start by understanding what your customers value most. For example, if your brand is known for premium products, offering discounts on future purchases might be more enticing than small freebies. On the other hand, experience-driven brands might find that exclusive access or VIP experiences have a stronger appeal. Walmart’s Rewards Program, for example, focuses on cashback for everyday purchases, which is highly relevant for cost-conscious shoppers. Meanwhile, luxury brands like Tiffany & Co attract high-spending clients by offering personalized, one-of-a-kind experiences.

Finding the right balance between practicality and excitement ensures that your rewards keep customers coming back, fostering long-term loyalty and strengthening their connection to your brand.

How to create a successful loyalty program

Creating a successful loyalty program goes beyond just setting up a rewards structure—it’s about strategically designing it around the customer journey to maximize its impact. Here’s a framework to help you get the most out of your program:.

• Simplify participation: Make it easy for customers to join and engage with your program. If they can quickly understand the benefits, they’re more likely to stick with it. For example, Starbucks Rewards lets customers automatically earn stars through the app with each purchase, which they can redeem for free drinks and food.
• Personalize experiences: Tailoring rewards based on a customer’s history with your brand not only boosts engagement but also makes their experience more meaningful. Loyalty programs that use data to offer personalized rewards can see up to 10-15% higher revenue, as they align rewards with individual preferences at each stage of the customer lifecycle. As you plan your program, think about the customer journey. What reward would make each stage more engaging?
• Encourage engagement beyond purchases: Rewards aren’t just for purchases. Incentivize customers for other valuable actions, like referrals or reviews, to build loyalty and bring in new customers. For example, Airbnb rewards users with travel credits for referring friends who sign up and book stays. By adding these touchpoints, your program stays relevant throughout a customer’s entire lifecycle.
• Leverage technology for seamless integration: Use apps or digital wallets to make rewards easily accessible anytime. These tools also enable tracking and personalization. For example, Target’s app integrates the Circle Rewards Program, allowing users to easily access personalized offers, track rewards, and redeem discounts directly from their phone.
• Adapt over time: The customer lifecycle isn’t a one-and-done thing, it’s a continuous loop of engagement. A well-designed program should evolve to meet customers’ changing preferences and keep them coming back. Continuously collect data, analyze trends, and refine rewards to keep your customers engaged throughout their journey with your brand.

Measuring the success of your loyalty program

Once your loyalty program is live, measuring its success is essential to understanding its impact on sales, customer retention, and overall brand loyalty. Tracking the right metrics helps you assess the program’s performance and pinpoint areas for improvement. Here are four key metrics to keep an eye on:

• Customer retention rate: The core goal of any loyalty program is to encourage repeat business, and tracking retention is key to understanding this. Are more customers coming back and engaging with your brand over time? According to Harvard Business Review, increasing retention by just 5% can boost profits by 25% to 95%. Monitoring retention shows how well your program fosters long-term relationships.
• Average spend per member: A key indicator of success is whether members are spending more than non-members. According to Accenture, loyalty program members spend up to 18% more than non-members. This metric not only shows retention but also highlights the program’s ability to increase customer value.
• Customer Lifetime Value (CLV): CLV measures the total revenue a customer is expected to generate over their entire relationship with your business. By tracking CLV, you can see if your loyalty program is extending the revenue-generating relationship with each customer. For example, Apple’s seamless integration across its products encourages customers to subscribe to services like iCloud or Apple Music, creating a continuous revenue stream and steadily increasing each customer’s CLV over time.
• Engagement metrics: Track active usage, reward redemptions, and app engagement (if applicable). High engagement often signals that the program is both relevant and rewarding.

To keep your loyalty program effective, make data-driven adjustments by collecting feedback through surveys to understand what members value and refine rewards. Analyze competitor programs to identify trends and best practices, keep the program fresh with limited-time or seasonal rewards, and use engagement and spending data to optimize rewards and maintain relevance.

Key takeaways

• Choose the right rewards: Pick rewards that match customer needs, combining instant and aspirational rewards to keep them engaged over time.
• Focus on simplicity and personalization: Make sure the program is easy to join and customize rewards based on individual customer preferences.
• Measure with key metrics: Track customer retention, average spend per member, and customer lifetime value to measure the program's effectiveness.
• Continuously improve: Collect feedback, analyze competitor programs, refresh rewards, and use data insights to keep the program running at its best.

The bottom line

Creating a successful loyalty program is about building a connection with your customers, not just handing out rewards. When done right, it drives repeat purchases, boosts brand recognition, and increases revenue. Top programs like those from Amazon, Walmart, and Starbucks make customers feel valued with perks that matter.

To keep your program effective, track key metrics like retention, spending, and lifetime value. Regularly update rewards, offer limited-time deals, and personalize experiences to keep customers engaged. A well-planned loyalty program doesn’t just offer rewards, it builds a loyal community that keeps choosing your brand.

---